Caulk and open windows cost little and fix little; the EPA treats sealing as a supplement, not a standalone method. The cheapest durable fix is activating an existing passive pipe with a fan. Otherwise, a right-sized active system is the value play.
More detail
The temptation to seal your way out is understandable and well studied: sealing alone rarely produces lasting reductions, because soil gas finds the openings that remain, and a Pittsburgh stone foundation has a lifetime supply. Window-opening works precisely as long as the windows are open, which is not a plan for a plateau winter. Where real economy lives: houses whose builders stubbed a passive pipe, common in post-1995 Cranberry, Wexford, and Robinson plans, where adding an attic fan, gauge, and labels runs $650 to $1,100 and delivers full active performance. Elsewhere, economy means right-sizing rather than corner-cutting: a single well-placed suction point proven by a communication test beats two guessed ones, an exterior route can save carpentry where aesthetics allow, and skipping the gauge or the verification test saves money in the way removing smoke-detector batteries does. The honest floor for a ground-up system in this market is the low end of our published ranges; meaningfully below that, ask what is missing. Run your own number through the calculator first.